ATO late lodgement penalty: up to $364 per 28 days, capped at $1,820 per document · interest 11.43% p.a. compounding daily · See how to remit them →
How a UPE happens, usually by accounting rather than intent
30 June arrives and the trustee resolves to distribute $150,000 to the corporate beneficiary, capping tax at the company rate. The company returns the income and pays its tax. But the trust keeps the cash, funding stock, the offset account, life.
On paper it is a distribution. In substance it is the company's money financing the trust interest free. That gap is the UPE, and it accumulates. Many family groups discover, at review, a decade of them stacked into the high six figures.
The two competing views
| ATO position (the operating reality) | Bendel (the challenge) | |
|---|---|---|
| Core claim | A company letting its UPE sit unpaid provides financial accommodation, which is a Division 7A loan | A UPE is an entitlement, not a loan, and the Division 7A loan definition does not reach it |
| Consequence | A complying loan agreement with minimum repayments is required, or a deemed unfranked dividend arises | No automatic Division 7A consequence for the UPE itself |
| Status | Long-standing rulings, maintained pending appeal, with interim guidance flagging alternatives such as section 100A and debt forgiveness angles | Full Federal Court found for the taxpayer, with a High Court appeal on foot |
What to actually do while it is unresolved
The compliance surface underneath
Whatever Bendel settles, the housekeeping failures around UPEs remain independently dangerous: trustee resolutions not made or not documented by 30 June, which invalidates the distribution and defaults the income to trustee assessment at 47%; distributions to beneficiaries who never see any benefit, which is section 100A's core target; and family groups whose trust and company returns are years unlodged, where nobody actually knows what the UPE ledger says.
The triage order is the usual one. Lodgments current first, then the ledger reconstructed, then the Division 7A and UPE repair strategy. The discretionary fixes all favour the party who raised the issue first.
Frequently asked questions
What is an unpaid present entitlement?
Is a UPE a Division 7A loan?
What is the Bendel case?
Should I unwind my Division 7A loan agreements over old UPEs?
What happens if trustee resolutions were not done by 30 June?
This page carries a visible last-reviewed date because the law here is genuinely in motion.
General information only - not personal tax, financial or legal advice. Consider your own circumstances or speak to a registered tax agent. Remission of penalties or interest and payment plans are decisions of the ATO and outcomes can't be guaranteed.